What Do You Do When You Like Two Guys, But Ones Dating Someone And You Have Liked Him Forever? But You Like The Other Guy Alot Too?

Well for all practical purposes if they are both in a dead heat for your interest then it would be best to start with the one who is not currently  involved in a relationship. If it does not work out by this time then maybe your other interest will have become available, and that will save you any trouble that might arise from you competing for him with someone else. It is all elementary my friend.  
Good Luck and may the love you are longing for find office your heart......

Play it safe. Don't mess with the one in the relationship.

Hey, choose only one.

Ummmm go for the guy who u think will treat u best... Ta tell you the truth i think you should go for tony..... Caz he treats his gfs wit respect.. And he really likes youu..... :) and ik this for a fat caz last night he told me he felt like he was goin to cry... :( but do wat makes you happy chick.... :) good luck.. :)

Keep it simple with the other guy... If the first guy breaks up or something dive.

Relax, take it easy, give it some time, a relationship is not something you should rush.

P.S. If number one is already taken - cross him off your list.