I'm dating this guy, but there is this other guy I really like and he asked me to make out with him. Should I?

You are dating one guy... And the other just wants to make out with you?  Stick to the one you are dating.  Number 2 sounds like a jerk.

If you have a good or at least a decent rep. Ima have to say you shouldnt do it but hey its your life to ruin so goodluck and make the right choice =D

Well if you think about it...
Do you like the guy you are dating? If yes...
Do you like the other guy more? If you do...
You need to think is he a player? Or...
Is he sweet and can hold a relationship? If he can't't hold one down then it's not worth it
hope this helps ! (:

; don't leave the one you love for the one you like ,, you need to let that other guy know that you are in a commited relationship that you don't want to mess up .. Would you want your boyfriend kissing on girls he liked ? Noo ... So just thinkk about it and use your head to figure it out .

If you leave the guy your with and this new relationship doesn't work out your going to be alone so id stick with the guy your with thats the best choice

No. That would be cheating and I bet your boyfriend would care very much about that. Doing this just causes more trouble; with your relationship with your boyfriend, and it may ruin the way others think of you.

If you were in love with the first you wouldn't be falling for the second..

Mayb you shouldnt be in a relationship if thats how you feel about your boyfriend do you just go around and kiss anybody?? You think that will make you feel good about your self?? Maybe your boyfriend deserves better!! But just remember what goes around comes around!!!! I'm just saying.....hope this helps!!

Threesome!!!! ;)

Well its not a problem if you date both of them as long as you'll be honest to both party .. Tell them the truth, I'm sure they understand ... Know them better ... And choose the best ... More power to you