If Your Family As Far As You Know Did Not Own Slaves, Does That Make America Less Guilty?

4

4 Answers

Kris Windom Profile
Kris Windom answered
I don't think that any American, whether their ancestors owned slaves or not, should feel guilty about what happened then.  That would be like saying that people with German heritage should feel guilty about the holocaust or Christians should feel guilty about the atrocities of the middle ages.  Throughout human history, mankind has used slaves.  This includes all races and some religions.  I will agree that what was done was cruel and wrong, but to keep trying to throw in the faces of people today is also wrong.  The past is just that.  The only way to recover from it is to acknowledge the facts, correct them and move on.
thanked the writer.
View all 4 Comments
nettie
nettie commented
I feel the holocaust was definitely wrong,you think people should be made,allowed to forget,these things were a part of life, how do you forget? you better remember so as to not let any repeats happen.
nettie
nettie commented
I have a german friend and he talks to me about this I wasn't there and I feel bad for him and don't know what to say at times, and he gets real emotional,how do you tell people to forget life..
nettie
nettie commented
How do you forget a portion of life,just hang on to the good and dump the bad?
jessica nix Profile
jessica nix answered
I don't think anyone should have to feel guilty for what their ancestors had done, unless they are doing it also. My father's mother's family is from Ireland (erin go bragh!) so i dunno if our family is fallen behind the ancestry of slavery. If it was, i would be not only mortified but shamed as well. Just thinking of how people treated others because of a simple thing as skin color. My daughter's father is Mexican.  but not even my father will discriminate against him. Why? Because that man has fathered his first grandchild. (and my father is very racist) America should only feel guilty for the things they let other people do that is as cruel as slavery.
thanked the writer.
nettie
nettie commented
that is basically the point,thank you,the question was derived from all the hoopla regarding Obama I won't vote for him but I won't defame him and his family either,I wouldn't do this to anyone.
NASSY NASCARNUT Profile
NASSY NASCARNUT answered
No.  Simply because it is a huge blemish on the reputations of all Americans whom disagree with the notion of one having to serve another because they have a God given tan!!!♥Nassy
thanked the writer.
nettie
nettie commented
thank you nassy,the question was concerning America"Goverment" not a single person,if you or your family had slaves that was the times,the question is treatment....Thanks
NASSY NASCARNUT
NASSY NASCARNUT commented
I BELIEVE I ANSWERED FOR ALL "AMERICAN PEOPLE"
Anonymous Profile
Anonymous answered
There own people sold them to the settlers, and my grandfather fought for their freedom and equality.
thanked the writer.
nettie
nettie commented
thank you for your answer,and so did I fight for all the things america hold dear,I was also in the war zone,treatment is the key don't you think,the question ws should america feel guilty,not anyone personal.

Answer Question

Anonymous